Receiving an incorrect Social Security payment—whether it’s more or less than expected—can be frustrating and even stressful. But don’t panic. Understanding why the error happened and knowing what steps to take can make the situation much easier to handle. This guide walks you through the common causes of errors, how to address both overpayments and underpayments, and what you can do to avoid future issues.
Table of Contents
Why Social Security Payment Mistakes Happen
The Social Security Administration (SSA) distributes benefits to over 70 million Americans every year. Given the complexity and scale, it’s no surprise that mistakes occasionally happen. Between 2015 and 2022, the SSA estimated about $72 billion in improper payments—primarily overpayments—though that still represents less than 1% of all benefits paid.
Common Reasons for Incorrect Payments
Unreported Income
Failing to report additional earnings, pensions, or other income sources can change your benefit eligibility and lead to overpayments.
Changes in Living Arrangements
If you move, get married, divorced, or someone else moves in or out of your household, these changes can affect your benefits—especially if you’re receiving Supplemental Security Income (SSI).
Administrative Errors
Mistakes can happen on the SSA’s end as well. A simple data entry issue or misinterpretation of eligibility criteria can lead to incorrect payments.
What to Do If You’ve Been Overpaid
Getting a notice that you’ve been overpaid can feel overwhelming, especially if you’ve already spent the money. Fortunately, you have options—and rights.
Step 1: Review the Overpayment Notice
The SSA will send a letter explaining the overpayment amount and the reason behind it. Read it carefully to make sure all details are accurate.
Step 2: File an Appeal
If you believe the SSA made a mistake, you can appeal the decision. Complete and submit Form SSA-561 (Request for Reconsideration) within 60 days of the date on your notice.
Step 3: Request a Waiver
If the overpayment wasn’t your fault and repaying it would cause financial hardship, request a waiver using Form SSA-632. There’s no deadline to file a waiver request.
Step 4: Negotiate a Repayment Plan
If repayment is required but the amount is unaffordable, you can work out a reduced payment plan using Form SSA-634 (Request for Change in Overpayment Recovery Rate).
What to Do If You’ve Been Underpaid
If your benefit amount seems too low—or if you didn’t receive a payment at all—take these steps to get the funds you’re owed.
Step 1: Contact the SSA Immediately
Call the SSA at 1-800-772-1213 or visit your local office to report the issue. The sooner you act, the better.
Step 2: Gather Evidence
You’ll need to provide documentation to support your claim. This may include bank statements, benefit letters, or proof of income.
Step 3: Ask for Expedited Processing
If the underpayment is causing significant financial hardship, inform the SSA and ask for your case to be prioritized.
How to Prevent Future Social Security Payment Issues
Staying proactive is the best way to avoid future mistakes and ensure you receive the correct amount each month.
Review Your Benefit Statements Regularly
Monitor your monthly or yearly statements to make sure the numbers add up.
Report Life Changes Right Away
Whether it’s a new job, a move, or a change in marital status, update the SSA immediately to avoid incorrect payments.
Create and Use a “my Social Security” Account
This free online tool lets you view benefit details, report changes, and communicate with the SSA more efficiently.
New Legislation Offering Protection for Seniors
In response to growing concern over aggressive overpayment recovery, lawmakers introduced the Social Security Overpayment Relief Act. This proposed legislation would:
- Prevent the SSA from reclaiming overpayments that are more than 10 years old
- Provide additional protections to seniors who unknowingly received excess funds
- Introduce more humane methods of debt recovery for low-income beneficiaries
This act is currently under review but signals a shift toward a more compassionate approach to managing payment errors.
Who Will Get the Next $1,545 Social Security Payment? Find Out the Payment Date & Eligibility
New $5,108 Social Security Payment Set for March 26 Who’s Eligible and How to Maximize Your Benefits
Eligibility and Schedule for February 2025 Social Security Payments
February 2025 SSI Payment of $484 Deposit Date and Eligibility Information
2025 Stimulus Checks Who’s Eligible, Payment Dates, and What You Need to Know
Final Thoughts: Take Action and Stay Informed
Errors in your Social Security payments can feel daunting, but they don’t have to be a long-term problem. By understanding the process, communicating with the SSA, and staying on top of your benefits, you can resolve issues quickly and help prevent them from happening again.
If you believe your payment is wrong, act now. The sooner you address the issue, the smoother the resolution will be.